Grand Rounds Recap 6.3.20


Event medicine: The Flying Pig marathon WITH Dr. divine

Event Priorities

  • Know the safety and medical needs of each individual within a large group

  • Know your budget

  • Develop a timeline and check-off

  • Have an operations manual

  • Volunteers: both recruitment and retention

Event Details

  • Know broad population needs. Example: for marathon you have runners, walkers and an audience

  • Have/share pre-established assessment and treatment protocols

  • Know the rules of the sporting event: adding a participant, official distances, etc

  • Be ready for surprise injuries: ex. dislocated jaw

Urgent/Emergent Care Capability

  • Providing care to participants as well as spectators (ex kid with anaphylaxis) including providers and event staff

  • Working with law enforcement and public safety

  • Risks for 2020: Clean, isolate, tracking


Crisis standards of care WITH dr. diller and dr. nomellini

Capacity Levels Leading to Crisis Standard of Care

  • Conventional Capacity: ability to continue usual standard of care increasing capacity to 20% above normal (ex. in mass causality situations) using existing staff and resources

  • Contingent Capacity: able to expand critical capacity 100%; modify existing spaces; re-deploying selected staff and augment ventilator supply (ex. vents for OR or transport, noninvasive ventilation); standard of care near prevailing community standard

  • Crisis Capacity: severe limitations of space, staff and supplies does not allow hospitals to provide the usual standard of care. Demand exceeds capacity and triage protocols become active

Triage to Achieve Standards of Care

  • Triage requires a community to accept that some individuals will not receive critical care resources as they normally would under normal circumstances.

  • Three overarching goals:

    • Deliver the greatest benefit to the greatest number of people

    • Prevent random or unequal distribution of resources

    • Provide compassionate supportive care to patients who do not receive critical care resources

  • Patient consent is not required to implement the allocation treatment plan for the patient

  • Triage incorporates multiple ethical principles (multi-principal approach).

Ethical Principles to Consider

  • Utilitarian: Priority is given to patients who are more likely to survive in the near-term as a consequence of care (ex. low SOFA, fewer organs failing) or given to patients who have a better prognosis after discharge

  • Stewardship: Patients who are too sick, near immediate death are not excluded form allocation

  • Save Two Lives: Priority is given to female patients who are pregnant with fetus > 24 weeks

  • Seasons of Life: Given comparable short term prognosis and long term prognosis, priority is given to younger patients

  • Equality: Priority is given to those who have a better lottery score (ex. lowest number, coin-flip)

  • Reciprocity: Front line workers and research subjects are given priority.


Disaster preparedness: Bio-threats WITH dr. kralovic

  •  Infectious disease epidemiology plays a factor in biologic events.

    • Host: immune status, genetics, age, gender, behaviors

    • Agent: virulence factors, genetic adaptability, infectivity

    • Environment: vector, reservoir, climate, land use, population density

  • The number of people that one sick person will infect (on average) is called Ro. Ro for several viruses listed below:

    • Hepatitis C - 2

    • Ebola - 2

    • HIV - 4

    • SARS - 4

    • Mumps - 10

    • Measles - 18

  • Phases of a pandemic:

    • Phases 1-3: Predominantly animal infections, few human infections

    • Phase 4: Sustained human to human transmission

    • Phases 5-6: Widespread human infection

    • Post Peak: possibility of recurrent events

    • Post Pandemic: disease activity at seasonal levels

  • Pandemic severity index (based on case fatality rate):

    • Category 1: <0.1%

    • Category 2: 0.1% - <0.5%

    • Category 3: 0.5 - <1.0%

    • Category 4: 1.0 - <2%

    • Category 5: >2%

  • Goals of Community Mitigation:

    • 1) delay outbreak peak

    • 2) decompress peak burden on hospitals/infrastructure

    • 3) diminish overall cases and health impacts